British Prime Minister Andy Burnham has delivered the bluntest verdict on Brexit yet from a sitting prime minister, telling an audience in London that it "has not worked" — and that Britain has lost more than it has gained since leaving the European Union.
Speaking at the Lord Mayor's Banquet on Monday, Burnham reached for a fairy tale to make his point. He compared the aftermath of Britain's divorce from the EU, triggered by the 2016 referendum, to Hans Christian Andersen's "The Emperor's New Clothes", in which nobody is willing to say the ruler is naked.
"I do try to say things as I see them," he said, according to reports of the speech. "And to be frank, we have lost more than we have gained in the last 10 years. The hard Brexit we were given is not good enough for Britain."
What Friday's summit could deliver
The remarks come just days before a UK-EU summit in Brussels on Friday, which Burnham has cast as a chance to reset a relationship that has been strained for a decade. He said the meeting could bring "real improvements in people's everyday lives in areas of the country that have felt neglected for too long".
The UK is expected to seal a deal on trading food and drink, with fewer border checks, alongside agreements on energy and emissions and a plan to let young people live and work for limited periods across Britain and the EU. Any deal, he said, would have to pass three tests: it must be consistent with Labour's manifesto and red lines, improve the Brexit deal to match what people voted for in 2016, and pass his "Makerfield Test" — his benchmark for making sure neglected parts of the country actually feel the benefit.
The numbers behind the argument
Burnham argued that the promise of the pro-Brexit campaign — that Britain would "take back control" of its borders, laws and economy — simply has not been delivered. Trade with EU countries has dropped sharply since departure, and he put the economic damage at between 4 percent and 8 percent of the UK's gross domestic product.
He also framed Brexit as part of a wider turn away from international cooperation. "Brexit was the first domino to fall in a global move towards more isolationism and protectionism," he said. "It is exactly what our enemies wanted. Russia wanted disunity within NATO and a weaker Europe."
What he is not offering
For all the bold language, Burnham stopped well short of reopening the question of membership itself. Until the next national election, due in 2029, he remains bound by the pledge of his predecessor Keir Starmer not to rejoin the bloc's tariff-free customs union or its frictionless single market for goods, services and workers.
He said he would open a discussion with EU partners on Britain's long-term relationship soon after the Brussels summit. His spokesperson, Tom Wells, said on Monday that "no assumptions are being made" and that "the British public will be the boss of any outcome".
That caution is understandable. The 2016 referendum split the country almost down the middle — 52 percent in favour of leaving, 48 percent in favour of remaining — and the subject has ended the careers of prime ministers ever since. Burnham, the seventh person to hold the job since that vote, is now betting that voters are ready for an honest conversation about the cost.
This is a developing story. The UK-EU summit takes place in Brussels on Friday, November 20.
