A federal judge in Virginia said on Friday she would block construction of President Donald Trump's proposed 250-foot triumphal arch near Arlington National Cemetery, handing the project its second court setback in just over a fortnight.
Judge Leonie Brinkema of the US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia told a hearing in Alexandria that she would grant Arlington County's request for a preliminary injunction, stopping work on the monument while the legal challenge continues, according to Bloomberg Law. Reuters reported that she described the project during the hearing as a "rushed job" that lacked a legal basis.
A second judge steps in
Brinkema was blunt about the government's chances. She said from the bench that the arch was a project "without congressional approval" and that she did not see "any way" the government could win the case on the merits, Bloomberg Law reported.
Her ruling makes her the second judge to halt the project. Judge Tanya Chutkan in Washington issued a temporary restraining order within an hour of the arch's final planning approval on 5 November, and extended that order for another two weeks on Wednesday.
The ruling landed as Mr Trump was briefing reporters at the White House on his trip to Asia, where he had held a first-ever three-way summit with China's Xi Jinping and Russia's Vladimir Putin.
Why the courts keep stopping it
The arch would stand 250 feet tall at Memorial Circle, between the Arlington Memorial Bridge and Arlington National Cemetery, to mark the 250th anniversary of the signing of the Declaration of Independence. It is designed to carry gold statues on top and would be roughly twice as large as the Lincoln Memorial, according to the Wall Street Journal.
The National Capital Planning Commission approved the final plans by eight votes to four on 5 November, after nearly nine hours of public testimony in which many speakers — including veterans — urged the panel to reject it. Within the hour, Judge Chutkan had halted any construction work.
The legal fight turns on whether the project needed Congress's permission first. Washington DC and Virginia sued on 31 October, arguing that it skipped environmental and historical reviews and that the Commemorative Works Act requires specific congressional authorisation for new monuments in the capital. The administration has pointed instead to a 1925 law authorising the Arlington Memorial Bridge, an argument Judge Chutkan rejected at the preliminary stage when she found the two governments were "likely to succeed".
The National Park Service, which oversees the project, has also admitted to the court that the construction company it used drew markings around the site without permission.
What happens next
The White House has been eager to move quickly. Mr Trump has said he wants the arch finished before he leaves office in two years, and officials have been keen to get work under way before the new Democratic-controlled Congress takes power in January.
For now, though, the project is frozen on two fronts. Brinkema's preliminary injunction is likely to delay construction for months while the Virginia case plays out, and Chutkan's order in Washington remains in force into next month. Neither ruling decides the case outright — but two judges have now said, in strikingly similar terms, that the government may not have the legal authority to build the arch at all.
This is a developing story — the injunction is preliminary, and the case will continue in court.
