Breaking
Russian missiles strike two key Kyiv bridges as overnight attacks rock Ukraine — full coverage on Daily Global Buzz
Advertisement

UK Tribunal Rules Government Can No Longer Hide Its Secret Order for Access to Apple Data

Advertisement


The British government can no longer pretend its secret order to Apple doesn't exist. That's the blunt message from a London tribunal, which ruled on Thursday that the Home Office must finally acknowledge it served the tech giant with a formal demand for access to customers' encrypted data.

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the government's argument that admitting the order exists would damage national security. In its ruling, the tribunal said ministers had "not established" that confirming the order would cause any such harm — not least because the order has been one of the worst-kept secrets in British tech policy for nearly two years.

A secret that wasn't secret any more

At the heart of the case is a technical capability notice, or TCN — an order issued under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 that can require a company to maintain the ability to hand over customer data in readable form, even when that data is encrypted.

For months, the Home Office refused to confirm or deny whether such a notice had been served on Apple, citing its long-standing "neither confirm nor deny" policy on security matters. But the tribunal found that position had become impossible to defend. According to Reuters, the government's own lawyers were told that so much information was already in the public domain that confirming the order would do "little, if any, damage".

The tribunal also pointed to the government's own conduct. Digital Watch, summarising the judgment, reported that the tribunal found the Home Office had departed from its secrecy policy in briefings to journalists and in discussions with US officials — departures that, in the judges' view, undermined its case for keeping the order hidden.

Civil rights groups had argued the secrecy was preventing any meaningful public debate. At a hearing in September, lawyers for Privacy International and Liberty described the refusal to confirm the order as an "affront to open justice". Akiko Hart, Liberty's director, called Thursday's ruling "a victory for transparency", adding: "The public deserve to know when the government's actions undermine their privacy and safety."

How the dispute got here

The row began in January 2025, when Britain issued its first notice to Apple, seeking access to encrypted iCloud backups belonging to US and British citizens. The demand set off a diplomatic storm, and after months of negotiations with President Donald Trump's administration, it was dropped. In August 2025, US Director of National Intelligence Tulsi Gabbard said publicly that the UK had agreed to withdraw the requirement as it affected American users.

But the story didn't end there. In July 2026, Britain issued a second, narrower notice, this time applying only to Apple's UK customers. Apple launched a fresh legal challenge, while Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals brought a separate case against the secrecy surrounding the order. In February 2025, Apple had already stopped offering its Advanced Data Protection feature — which adds end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups, photos and notes — to new users in the UK.

The government, responding to the ruling, insisted that the right to privacy was crucial but "should not come at the expense of public safety". A spokesperson said Apple had "been helping the police and intelligence agencies pursue criminals and bring them to justice for several years, in accordance with the law", and that the notice "simply requires that they maintain the ability to do so".

What the ruling doesn't decide

For all its significance, Thursday's judgment settles only one question: whether the order's existence can be acknowledged. It does not say whether the order itself is lawful, and it does not reveal what Apple has actually been asked to do. The tribunal also handed down private judgments that it said could not be disclosed without "damaging the public interest".

That means the bigger fight is still to come. A full hearing on whether the notice — and the wider system of secret capability orders — is lawful is not expected until next year, with campaigners expecting the substantive arguments to be heard in 2027. Until then, the order exists in a strange halfway state: officially confirmed, but with its contents still sealed.

The case matters well beyond Britain. End-to-end encryption is now the default for billions of messages, photos and backups around the world, and governments everywhere are wrestling with the same tension — how to give police lawful access to evidence without weakening the security that protects everyone else's data. Thursday's ruling doesn't resolve that tension. But it does mean the argument about it can now happen in the open.

This is a developing story: the full hearing on whether the order is lawful is expected next year, and the tribunal will separately decide what, if anything, can be revealed about what the notice actually requires.

Advertisement
Advertisement